How to Choose the Right Tattoo Studio and Artist in NYC

So, you’ve finally decided to get a tattoo — exciting! Whether it’s your first or fifth, there’s always that mix of excitement and nerves. You’re probably thinking about the design, the placement, and the size. If it’s your first tattoo, you might even wonder whether to start small or go big. (We’ll save that topic for another post!)

For now, let’s focus on something even more important — how to choose the right tattoo studio and artist. Tattoos are forever, and your experience should be as memorable as the artwork itself.

1️⃣ Find a Reputable, Safe, and Clean Studio

In a city as big as New York City, there are hundreds of tattoo studios to choose from — but not all are created equal. Therefore, start with reputation and safety.

• • Check reviews: A few bad reviews happen to everyone, but if a shop has more negative than positive feedback — especially recent ones — that’s a red flag.
  • Look for improvement: Reviews over three years old don’t always reflect how a business operates today. Focus on recent experiences.
  • Cleanliness matters: The studio should look and feel clean, using gloves, sterile tools, and single-use needles for every client.

At Red Baron Ink, we’re proud to be an APP-certified (Association of Professional Piercers) studio, maintaining the highest standards for safety, sanitation, and jewelry quality — because your health and comfort always come first.

2️⃣ Pay Attention to Customer Service

A great tattoo experience goes beyond the ink. It’s also about how you’re treated from start to finish. Moreover, customer service sets the tone for the entire experience.

• Were you greeted warmly when you walked in or reached out?
• Did the staff answer your questions and make you feel comfortable?
• Do they seem genuinely interested in your idea, or do they just want to tattoo you and move on?

You deserve to feel respected, informed, and cared for. A professional artist will want you to love your tattoo just as much as they love creating it. In addition, a well-run studio focuses on clear communication and comfort every step of the way.

3️⃣ Choosing Your Artist — The Fun Part

Once you’ve found a reputable studio, it’s time to narrow down your artist. Start by researching tattoo styles — from American Traditional and Neo-Traditional to Fine Line, Blackwork, Realism, Watercolor, Abstract, Lettering, and Portraits — all styles we offer here at Red Baron Ink.

When you reach out:

• Share reference photos and describe your vision clearly.
• Ask to see artist portfolios that align with your design goals.
• Browse their work on Instagram or the studio website to see whose style speaks to you.

Choosing an artist whose work inspires you ensures the best experience — it’s a creative partnership built on trust, passion, and collaboration.

4️⃣ Schedule a Consultation

Before you commit, schedule a consultation. It helps you connect with your artist, discuss ideas, and make sure they’re as excited about your piece as you are. That energy will always show in the final tattoo.

At Red Baron Ink, we take pride in matching each client with the right artist based on your design, references, and goals. We want you to feel comfortable, confident, and inspired every step of the way.

✨ Final Thoughts

Getting a tattoo isn’t just about the art — it’s about trust, connection, and experience. Choose a studio that values safety and customer care, and an artist who’s as passionate about your idea as you are. Furthermore, remember that your body art tells your story — so choose wisely, and let’s make it one worth showing off.

To learn more about our safety practices, check out our Piercing Aftercare page for details on how we maintain a clean and welcoming environment.

For additional information on piercing safety standards, visit the Association of Professional Piercers (APP).

Red Baron Ink Tattoo & Piercing
West Village, NYC
APP-Certified | Safe | Friendly | Artist-Driven
Book Your Consultation Today »